Evolution of the relation between “building” and “structure” until Viollet le Duc
The role of new technologies and new theoretical instruments

by Salvatore Di Pasquale

It is important to make clear what meaning the term “structure” has been acquiring over time. It originally comes from the Latin word struhere that precisely means “to build”. We may find an exhaustive answer if we consider the term “structure” in its abstract meaning. The latter is reported in all vocabularies where it is defined as the relation between various parts and, in particular, between various elements of a building that have a static function. Viollet le Duc’s vivid intelligence didn’t fail to observe that large stone buildings reveal epochs that can be characterized by the relevance they assign to the structural function and the way it is translated into clearly identifiable symbols. Viollet le Duc understood that prior to any rigorous structural analysis of a building it is indispensable to identify the pressure curve linking the loads that help to find the best solution. We shouldn’t forget though that Viollet’s education wasn’t the least connected with the language of mathematics. And we may therefore ask ourselves what did he possibly see to come to such an undoubtedly true and striking conclusion: not the forces with which the pressure curve is built since they are a mental construction, but rather the effects they produce or say, the fractures that happen to be clearly visible. The idea that such an analysis could be carried out even for a structure made of material rather resistant to tensile stress, almost unable to support this kind of efforts, was soon developed. At the end of the 19th century, C.A. Castigliano made a first step in this direction when he proposed the analysis of railway bridges built with dry stone ashlars. The methodology, though undoubtedly valuable, failed to take into account the stress to diminish tension regime. Although the way was almost defined by then, the trend of theoretical and experimental researches to focus on steel and reinforced concrete put immediately an end to the newly opened chapter on the calculation of stone building. Today, things are completely different. On the one hand, it is possible to use new instruments of structural calculation that inform us on the state of stress in any structure, whatever the shape. On the other hand, innovative materials and techniques - acknowledgeable with the abbreviation FRP (Fiber Reinforced Polimer) - offer many opportunities for the future.